How to Design Recognition Programs That Retain Top Government Talent
While many public sector workers are motivated by a passion for the job, it is nice to feel appreciated. Learning how to create an effective employee recognition program is essential for retaining skilled and experienced government personnel.
Do Employee Recognition Programs Actually Work?
Research shows that private-sector appreciation programs considerably increase engagement and motivation among employees. Participants are more likely to report higher levels of loyalty, job satisfaction and ambition, contributing to a positive workplace culture. Do these same effects apply to government workers?
The public sector’s bureaucratic nature can make implementing such programs challenging. However, they tend to perform well because workers often feel fulfilled by providing a public service and fulfilling the organization’s mission. Many are driven by a sense of purpose rather than by money alone.
These programs benefit the agencies implementing them as much as they do government employees. Engaged, motivated personnel are less likely to seek employment elsewhere. Given that SHRM research shows hiring a new employee costs $5,000 on average, organizations can save money and time by strategically recognizing workers’ efforts.
When Do These Programs Have the Greatest Impact?
Weekly praise shows workers whether they are on the right track, eliminating the guesswork. Providing clarity reinforces desirable behaviors.
Research from employee recognition software provider Achievers shows people are three times more engaged and 2.6 times more productive when they receive recognition at least once per week. Achievers states: “Weekly recognition doesn’t just feel good, it gives employees a clear feedback loop that helps them stay focused, confident, and energized. When recognition is frequent, employees don’t waste time guessing whether they’re on the right track; they already know. That clarity boosts motivation, and reinforces the behaviors leaders want more of.”
Effectiveness hinges on how often employees receive recognition and on who is providing the praise. Whether they receive it from a colleague, a direct supervisor or a high-level superior determines their perception and gratitude.
According to analytics and advisory firm Gallup, the key is to know what makes recognition meaningful. In one of its surveys, 28% of people agreed that the most memorable recognition comes from managers. Most appreciated public acknowledgement via a certificate, award or commendation. Private recognition, glowing reviews, promotions and monetary gifts were among the other most noteworthy rewards.
What to Include in Your Program to Retain Top Talent
Due to budget constraints and regulations, agencies may be unable to offer monetary rewards. Only some have discretionary authority to grant lump-sum cash awards based on a high rating of record. This limitation is actually beneficial, as people may respond better to noncash recognition.
According to recognition product provider Successories, one of the best ways to create an effective employee recognition program is by rewarding employees with noncash gifts or awards. “While most people are uncomfortable bragging about cash, with tangible noncash incentives being visible and socially acceptable to praise, question or bring up, employees can enjoy talking about their latest award or recognition certificate, new desk accessory, poster or card,” it states.
Employers can bestow plaques and certificates, award custom trophies, and provide written and verbal praise. A high-quality, physical reward is evidence of their efforts, achievements and work ethic. While big ceremonies make top performers feel special, appreciation is often a low-cost endeavor. Managers can send personalized notes or offer praise on a job well done.
Weekly praise shows workers whether they are on the right track, eliminating the guesswork. Providing clarity reinforces desirable behaviors.
Tips for Creating an Effective Recognition Program
Following these three best practices can help public sector agencies create truly effective employee recognition programs to increase engagement and retention.
Give Gifts Top-Down
Rewards are often top-down — initiated by leadership and directed toward subordinates — for a reason. It is generally in poor taste to incentivize employees to pool resources to give trophies or cash gifts to higher-ups who earn more than they do. The adverse effects may be considerable if they feel their work is underappreciated.
Use Reward Systems
Agencies should consider using software designed to manage and automate recognition programs. Streamlining processes and documenting rewards supports culture alignment and ensures all team members are adequately recognized.
Be Selective With Gifts
In its Incentives and Recognition Evidence Review, CIPD — a member organization for human resources and people development — found recognition tends to demotivate only if it is seen as unfair, exploitative or irrelevant. However, if agencies reward employees simply for completing tasks rather than exceeding performance standards, they adversely affect work performance.
Retain Top Government Talent With Rewards Programs
Creating an effective employee recognition program is straightforward, as public sector workers appreciate even simple gestures, such as personalized notes. Experts have shown that weekly incentives that come from management are the most effective. It does not take much effort to show appreciation, and the results are well worth it.
Want new articles before they get published? Subscribe to our Awesome Newsletter.