Unleashing the Power of Government Talent: Why Management Matters

An older man with short, light gray hair and fair skin is shown against a blue background. He is wearing a light gray polo shirt and has a serious expression on his face, reminiscent of an executive often seen by employers in corporate settings.
Howard Risher has 40 years of experience as a consultant and HR executive with clients in every sector. He has published frequently in HR journals and websites.  He is the author or co-author of six book and a growing list of ebooks. The most recent is Building the Workforce Government Needs.  He is associated with Grahall Consulting Partners.

Chapter 1

Investing in Proven Management Practices That Pay Off

Note: This is an edited version of the first chapter in a soon-to-be-published ebook

It was clear at the start of President Trump’s second term when he created the Department of Government efficiency (DOGE), led by Elon Musk, that ‘better government’ was not his goal. The White House announced in February 2025 that President Trump was “committed to reducing the size and scope of the federal government.” But the election made it clear had different expectations.

A day after the election Stier posted his congratulations for those who won election, and went on to state, “Elected office carries an obligation to make our government institutions work for the people . . ..” Improving government performance is the goal of this book.

The Pew Public Trust in Government index has documented a drop in public trust. In September 2025, the index was at 17 percent and only 2 percent trusted government “to do what is right ‘just about always.’”

Another survey conducted by the Partnership found only 37 percent “believe the impact of the federal government on the country is positive.”  That is a profound problem that cannot be ignored.

Former Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley posted a brief discussion of a simple idea in 2024 of what’s needed in a column on the Barrett & Greene website: “A Compelling Scorecard for Democracy.” He argued,

“Have you ever noticed how little kids play differently on a soccer field when someone is keeping score?  The same can be said of those human beings we elect to run our state governments. But the problem is that hardly anyone is keeping score.”

“Measures define success in every field imaginable except one: government.”

“. . . now we have somewhere close to 24 million people employed in  . . . government, overseeing close to over $12 trillion in annual spending. And the obvious question is, what do we get for that money?”

That is a central question. He argued the public needs “a public, trusted, data‑driven scorecard” to track government performance because “hardly anyone is keeping score.” He frames the absence of clear, credible performance information as a weakness in government management — one that leaves citizens guessing whether their local district is improving or declining. That information should be available to each agency’s constituency.

A partial answer to O’Malley’s question was posted on a new website, americaspulse.org, which focuses on the power of citizens. From the website, “It’s time we held our elected officials accountable for solving the problems we all care about.”  The website reports performance data to give “We the People, the tools to both set our government’s priorities as well as to measure progress.”

Government has a start. The practice of defining agency performance goals is now nearly universal, but typically no one is seen as accountable for achieving the goals.

Government performance has long been a public concern, but it was not until David Osborne and Ted Gaebler published, Reinventing Government in 1992 that the focus shifted to performance results.

The authors focused on what is needed to “deliver high-quality goods and services” – the steps agencies and their leaders should consider to improve results. Former President Bill Clinton was quoted on the cover: “This book gives us a blueprint . . .” for better government.

Significantly, the 1990s was the decade businesses broke away from the common ‘do-what-you’re-told’ approach to supervision. More recently, the pandemic forced employees to rethink management practices. Now its AI that is forcing employers to rethink work.

This book brings together the knowledge of proven practices to contribute to improved performance. Now leaders need to consider what’s needed to create a high performance workplace.

The Framework for Managing Results

The use of performance goals and metrics to track improvements started a century ago. In the private sector goal setting or management-by-objectives dates to the 1960s and 70s. Today that’s a universal practice in business.

In the early 1990s the Congress agreed on the need to improve agency performance and passed the Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA). The Act required agencies to set goals, measure what matters, review progress, and make results public. But federal law does not hold anyone accountable for achieving goals.

The focus on goals and performance metrics actually started in state and city agencies in the late 1980s and has since become a common practice at all levels of government.

The election and the public’s concern with corruption now makes government accountability far more prominent. Clearly current practices have not solved the performance problems.

A proven but simple answer for holding executives, managers and employees accountable is Tennessee’s switch to the use of S.M.A.R.T. goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) for managing performance. This is a key point – everyone is accountable for their individual performance. This was the basis for the state’s reform.

To highlight a key issue, the use of S.M.A.R.T. goals is a verifiable and defensible answer to the problem with annual appraisal ratings. Possibly more important it provides a framework for managers and staff to discuss performance throughout the year.

An added problem, however, is that agencies are limited in their ability to react to operating problems by laws, regulations, standard procedures, union contracts, political differences, etc. – that is by the bureaucracy.

Prominent among the controls are civil service laws. Many were enacted early in the last century. Civil service commissions – as “guardians of the merit system” – enforce laws from a different era. That is a barrier to new practices. There is also a lack of trust; workers are skeptical and often resistant to change.

Government’s management problems are complicated by the diversity of agencies. It’s like a business ‘conglomerate;’ each agency has somewhat different management problems.

The problems are exacerbated by elected officials and appointees with little or no experience managing in organizations as large as the typical agency. Plus, they typically serve for relatively short periods.

Those constraints are the reason government operates with what has been called a “compliance culture.” That was highlighted in a 2018 National Academy of Public Administration (NAPA) when a team coined the phrase to describe the common culture in government. Where there is a compliance culture, employees focus on following rules, meeting requirements, and avoiding mistakes – they comply – rather than improving results.

As discussed in later chapters, the most successful companies started decades ago to invest in creating a work environment that is very different from the ‘bureaucratic model.’

Two workers in business suits shaking hands, symbolizing agreement or partnership, with a blurred office background.
A man in a suit presents project statistics on a screen to four workers seated at a conference table with laptops, notebooks, and papers in a modern office meeting room with plants.

A proven but simple answer for holding executives, managers and employees accountable is Tennessee’s switch to the use of S.M.A.R.T. goals. 

HOWARD RISHER

Global Studies Support Investing in a Different Management Paradigm

In early 2026 the World Bank released the report, “Public Workforce Performance and Prosperity,” a 100+ page study that argues,

“Citizens expect governments to deliver services efficiently, equitably, and with integrity and accountability. . . enhancing public sector workforce performance is not just a priority; it is a decisive step toward driving meaningful change and unlocking shared prosperity.”

The research was across 151 countries and surveys of government employees in 30 countries. The report highlighted ways to improve performance, and develop a list of 13 “Strategic Reform Priorities” related to improving workforce performance. The last on the list is “Management by empowerment.”

The message is clear: governments have failed to adopt the workforce management practices proven to improve performance and results. When employees are highly engaged and well managed, they are more productive, make fewer errors, and generate higher customer satisfaction.

The Bank’s argument is consistent with the 20 year research record of the World Management Survey (WMS) that has ‘measured’ and evaluated management practices across business, hospitals, and schools. The WMS research confirms that “ . . . middle managers are the overlooked key to maintaining a high performance work environment.”

Perhaps most important is a statement adopted by the OECD in 2019, confirming the importance of workforce management: “Recommendation of the Council on Public Service Leadership and Capability.” The OECD also addresses performance in their biennial Government at a Glance reports and in its series, Public Governance Reviews.

The potential for improved performance is best illustrated by Gallup’s studies of the performance gains when workers are highly engaged. Employee engagement is assessed with a small number of survey questions. Their survey results have been consistent for almost 30 years

These studies are very different but reached the same conclusion – when organizations break away from the historical “top-down” management practices, not just ‘workers’ but everyone is capable of performing at significantly higher levels. It’s relevant at all organization levels. That is a global reality.

The practices are prominent in the firms leading Fortune’s lists of the “Best Companies to Work For®” every year.

The Goal of This Book

In this book readers will learn about the work management changes known to create better performing organizations. It integrates proven practices focused on goal-based management and the use of metrics with the latest talent management practices proven over the past three decades. The focus is effective management and improved agency performance.

Governments around the world have aging workforces and should expect growing worker shortages. Well-qualified entry-level workers are needed, but the demographic trends suggest the pool of job seekers will get progressively smaller. Rebuilding workforces will be a related problem.

In later chapters, Tennessee’s government reform is recommended as a model. The state’s strategy for improving performance was based on steps proven to improve performance. This was government reform. The governor and his cabinet relied on policies and practices proven in other sectors.

Workers want their employer to be seen as successful and highly regarded. Most would be anxious to play a role in improving their work environment. That was proven in Tennessee. That record is discussed in later chapters.

A second but not secondary problem is creating a work environment that attracts and retains the better qualfied young talent. The best qualfied applicants get job offers from private employers – often with a higher salary – much faster than from public agencies.

A recent survey  of young “high-achiever” job seekers shows the “greatest importance is how people are treated at work” followed by work–life balance. “Social impact remains central.” They look for opportunities to “impact” human rights, increase access to healthcare, eliminate poverty/hunger, and improve the environment. Public agencies need to convince job seekers they are ready to provide those opportunities.

Work management practices have changed dramatically from the era when civil service systems were created. A number of “experts” have argued government management practices are outdated and obsolete.

At the federal level, the history of the “demo projects” that followed the Civil Service Reform Act confirms it is fully possible to gain agreement on policies and practices that create a positive workplace for employees. In each project, employees were heavily involved. Tennessee’s reform made the state one of the state’s better employers.

Significantly, the work management practices in high performance organizations make it easier for managers and their people to work together. There is mutual trust and a higher level of agreement on daily work activities. Employees love working in that environment. The shared focus is on improving results.

An important but often forgotten point is that working in an organization that improves the lives of people produces higher morale, stronger engagement, deeper commitment, and better performance. People like working in those organizations. That is an opportunity for government.

Four sources reporting research in organizations – McKinsey, Gallup, Deloitte, and HBR – have made that point on website posts. Overall, research confirms having a great place to work is “a performance multiplier.”

Despite the differences in agency management problems and different histories of failed change efforts, a proven solution is redefining the manager’s role and approach to supervision. It requires an investment in retraining and the time to support culture and behavior change at all levels. Truly effective managers are a key to high performance.

On paper there is nothing to prevent public agencies from becoming high performance organizations. Countries would benefit. The public would also benefit.

Elected officials as well as employees should commit to the goal of improving performance. Redefining the role of managers and empowering workers will assure continued improvement. It’s vital to rebuilding public support.

Want new articles before they get published? Subscribe to our Awesome Newsletter.

Accessibility

Pin It on Pinterest